Sean Scoopmire Presents Webinar on Content-Neutral Sign Regulations

Sean Scoopmire recently presented a webinar, Signs of the Times: Mastering Content-Neutral Ordinances, with James Carpentier, AICP, the Director of the International Sign Association, and Dawn Jourdan, J.D., Ph.D., the Dean of the School of Architecture, Planning & Preservation at the University of Maryland. They discussed several important topics for sign regulations, including constitutional free speech protections and the need for content neutrality. The webinar was a part of the Planning Webcast Series, presented by the Ohio Chapter of the American Planning Association.

Click here to watch the full recording of Signs of the Times: Mastering Content-Neutral Ordinances on YouTube.

Sign Regulations Must Comply with the First Amendment

The Supreme Court has reviewed sign regulations in two important decisions over the past 10 years. Before the decisions in these cases, many local government regulations categorized signs by their content.

For example, a sign code might provide one allowance for a “political sign” and another for a “directional sign.” In Reed v. Town of Gilbert, 576 U.S. 155 (2015), the Court held that these types of content-based sign regulations must meet the strict scrutiny standard and invalidated an ordinance that provided different size and time allowances for temporary signs with different messages. Because the strict scrutiny standard is difficult to meet, content-neutral sign regulations will fare better in Court.

Another common regulatory strategy distinguishes between on- and off-premises signs to limit billboards. In City of Austin v. Reagan National Advertising, LLC, 596 U.S. 61 (2022), the Court found that distinctions between on- and off-premises messages are location-based, so they do not run afoul of the content-neutrality requirement in Reed. Therefore, sign regulations can distinguish between on- and off-premises signs.

Best Practices for Content-Neutral Sign Regulations

As a result of Reed and Reagan National, cities and counties should review their sign regulations to ensure that they are content neutral. Several strategies for content-neutral sign regulations discussed in the webinar are:

  • Defining signs by their physical characteristics rather than their content;
  • Limiting height and area to harmonize signs with the character of each zoning district;
  • Restricting the use and type of lighting and other sign features in certain districts;
  • Providing setbacks for specific types or sizes of signs; and
  • Limiting the duration of display for temporary signs.

White Smith Cousino strives to incorporate these principles and other best practices into sign code updates for local governments. To learn more about recent sign code updates we’ve completed, click here.